Were the founding fathers democratic reformers the united states possesses the oldest written constitution of any major power the 55 men who attended the philadelphia convention of 1787 could scarcely have dreamed that 200 years later the nation would venerate them as the most enlightened statesmen of their time. More essay examples on federalism rubric roche's argument he states that the government was as democratic as possible: my concern is with the further position that not only were they revolutionaries, but also they were democrats. John p roche published a thesis the founding fathers a reform caucus in action where managed to dwell upon the significance of the contribution made by the builders of a country. -the founding fathers were first and foremost superb democratic politicians they met at the constitutional convention where they were going to set up the framework for the constitution the convention was a nationalist reform caucus which had to operate with great delicacy and skill in a political. I do not think the founding fathers were democratic reformers howard zinn makes a very compelling argument, focusing on the politicians' wealthy backgrounds and slavery- centered lifestyles due to their education, the founding fathers seemed to write the constitution based and around their own experiences, and influenced in ways that were.
Roche begins his essay by describing the constitutional convention as a democratic reform caucus this is central to roche's argument regarding the intentions of the founding fathers. Roche's thesis is that the founding fathers were essentially good people and that the framing of the constitution was a fairly democratic process that equally addressed state, economical, and political interests. Were the founding fathers democratic reformers place a similar order with us or any form of academic custom essays related subject and it will be delivered within its deadline all assignments are written from scratch based on the instructions which you will provide to ensure it is original and not plagiarized. Were the founding fathers democratic reformers no, a historian name charles beard draws another view of the founding fathers he states that, the rich must in their own interest, either control the government directly or control the laws by which government operates.
According to zinn, the founding fathers were not democratic reformers i agree with that opinion the fifty-five men who contributed to the constitution were mostly men of wealth and conservative minded. The founding fathers were a long way from being democratic reformers - they were democratic developers (except for the slaves and native americans) those two segments of america's social order, were outside the loop. The founding fathers universally rejected democracy and hoped that posterity would never turn the united states into one the word they used was republic, which is not synonymous with democracy. Taking sides (issue 7) during the colonial period, the issue whether the founding fathers were democratic reformers was raised the historian roche insisted that the founding fathers utilized their powers to create a constitution that supported the needs of the nation and was acceptable to the people.
Partially because i feel strongly that the founding fathers had the correct intentions in mind, and partially because i am an overconfident asshole who likes to argue, i volunteered to be a leader of a class wide debate (class wide meaning the entire lecture hall of like 200 people. Below is an essay on were the founding fathers democratic reformers from anti essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples founding fathers of the united states of america were males who fought to achieve one common goal, liberty for americans. The united states constitution and the federalist papers influenced united states history the founding fathers: a reform caucus in action by john roche and the constitution as an elitest document by michael parenti are constitutional debates that influenced american history and the power elite. Review structure of long essay questions and begin brainstorm work on first essay assignments: thomas paine's common sense questions due monday (10/16) were the founding fathers democratic reformers.
First off, many of the founding fathers were wealthy, came from good families and were well educated howard zinn states that the founding fathers based the constitution off of their own personal experiences without considering the past experiences of the average citizen. The founding fathers of the ruling people's democratic party (pdp) had a controversial informal agreement sometimes in 2002 of rotating (zoning) of strategic elective positions along the country's north and south axis. After reading both view points of john p roche and howard zinn, i felt like there were more things to back up the arguments made by zinn, which is one of the reasons why i think that the founding fathers were not in fact democratic reformers. There are many views as to what the motivations of the founding fathers were this can be examined with a study of the founding fathers, by john p roche, and framing the constitution, by charles a beard. No, the founding fathers were not democratic reformers there are a few reasons behind my opinion a lot of the delegates at the constitutional convention held substantial amounts of continental securites that would sharply increase in value if a strong national government were established.
Roches thesis is that the founding fathers were essenti exclusivelyy good raft and that the skeleton of the constitution was a fairly democratic assist that equ whollyy address dry land, economical, and political posts. Senators were originally appointed to their seats because of the founding fathers' distrust some big name founding fathers: john adams samuel adams benjamen franklin john hancock thomas jefferson slaveholding power manipulated so winning these states is the best way to win electoral votes giving more importance to some states, some people over. I agree with the author alfred f young on his argument that the founding fathers were not democratic reformers they were mostly made up of an elite group of college educated lawyers, merchants, slaveholding planters, and 'monnied men'.
Howard zinn gives more accompanying evidence as to why the founding fathers were not democratic reformers but rather, a selectshow more content four groups, beard noted, were not represented in the constitutional convention: slaves, indentured servants, women, men without property. The founding fathers are not considered democratic reformers they were anti-monarchist republicans (small r) who believed in the concept of a constitutional republic they believed that voters should be limited to male landowners or property owners the term democratic was not used. The question lies were the founding fathers democratic reformers john roche is arguing for the notion and howard zinn is against it these two make great points and i found without more research it is near to impossible to know for sure.